Having lived in Atlanta for years, Cynthia and Mike Davis found themselves yearning for a simpler, small-town way of life—if only they could find the ideal spot. During a motorcycle trip around the South to celebrate their wedding anniversary, they stopped in Eufaula, Alabama, for lunch. The town’s quaintness charmed them, and as they ate, they began eyeing it as a place to put down fresh roots. “We were sitting there, and we said, ‘You know, we love Eufaula,’” Cynthia says.
A house hunt soon afterward turned up an 1889 Victorian cottage in the historic district, left to languish but still beautiful beneath the decay. With the goal of keeping the architectural integrity intact, the Davises set about restoring its glorious surfaces and details, which include long-leaf pine shingles and…